Artists always work from reference, be it actual photos or models or previous artwork.
What would be wrong is doing a straight copy and then selling it for profit
Whoever did the concept art obviously liked the expression and position of the head
Keep in mind the final thing will be a 3D model. So he's not going to keep the face position or expression. Bessides the face and monster as a whole isn't that original, I saw 1000s variations on the same demonic styles in copy of old commics books (Vampirella) as well as in new ones. Pretty sure a lot of fantasy artists did similar artwork.
As for the wings, It's a fairly typical batwing shape, and the concept art didn't even kept the same wingspan or position
Bessides, from the quality of the face, it's obviously done
Guys, if you want to complain, at least complain about something worth complaining about ... such as the Daedric Dagger, which is pretty much a replica of a popular fantasy dagger sold as some shop, which could very well itself be inspired from previous movie/comic book or even (quite often) actual historical ceremonial dagger... big deal really
Almost as bad as the guy that complained the Daedric armor looked similar to some Nazgul armor sold on the web, which IMO looked like replica of Angus McBride middle earth painting which are then insipired from Frazetta which obviously drew inspireation from Vikings, Ancient russia, Ancient India and other historical sources
I had the chance to talk with Roger Zelazny many years ago (the author of the awesome 9 princes in Amber fantasy serie). He told me he had an impressive library full of reference and that he drew inspiration from historical sources such as the tarot and the kabala to build up his cosmology. No wonder it feel so real and so detailled.
Every writter do that. Every Artist do that.
If you read any book on painting by Boris Valejo, you will learn that using good references is just as important as using your imagination. Your art will not feel real if you don't look at the real world and use real reference.
Just try to draw a realistic hand and you'll be in for a few surprises.
I usually stayed out of all those funny discussions you guys have over here, but that one is a bit over the edge.
If anything I've always been a staunch defender of copyrights, but we're talking ... concept art here... not a book for sale ;D
Oh, and if you need fuel for complaints, that troll is a crossbreed of Arena Trolls and Willows (the movie)'s Trolls
OMG Tolkien infringed on the whole european mythos copyright, he should be burned ! He copied elves, dwarves... everything ! What an evildoer he must be !
Well... I'm glad he did.
Some current corporation took down some morrowind mod sites because someone dared to mod armor based on Marvel designs (The black knight, iron man and captain america)
If you ask me, that corporate giant was a bit dumb, as letting those mod lived would have no doubt been beneficial marketing-wise. Morrowind is not a superhero game. So it doesn't cut any potential income. It's pretty much equivalent to releasing a suit of armor with the pepsi logo on the shield. Free publicity.
As for that artwork, if I was the owner of the painting, I would no doubt give the ok, and perhaps ask for a little publicity (inspired by so and so...) I would not go AMOK
First the theme song, which IMO was almost a direct rip of the Pirates of the Caribbean movie theme
MMM saw the movie and didn't recognize it. if you asked me it sounded like soule usually sound like, and the part are rather... err.. I don't want to offend your obvious deep musical knowledge... but they were rather classical. I'm sure I can find lots of music that look like this one. Soule isn't the most imaginative, althought I do like some of his work, the opening title for morrowind, and - what's in my opinion is some of his best work - the stuff he did on icewind dale.
By the way, back to the imp, Wormgod did take that picture as reference. so he's pretty honest about it. IMO I'm surprised he didn't use some work by Valejo as a base. But as I said I got about 100s of pices of artwork that look nearly the same. in fact it's pretty close to the Marvel Style used in Doctor Strange too. Not espicially extravangantly original if you ask me.
Chefe said:
Fucking shit. Bethesda's is a direct copy, right down the the wings.
First the theme song, which IMO was almost a direct rip of the Pirates of the Caribbean movie theme, and now this.
Any word, MSFD?