Higher Animal
Arcane
- Joined
- Aug 11, 2012
- Messages
- 1,854
Nah, it promotes circle-jerking.
BUT CERTAIN GAMES DON'T BELONG IN THE TOP 50 RPG LIST!
Feels like we're giving a handicap to the pre-1997 games... also, we have a separate voting for consoles, and all that talk about "Codex is for PC RPGs"
We should handicap earlier games. It's entirely possible that Betrayal at Krondor is the greatest rpg ever made but will never be reflected in a list by people who have never and will never play it.
Nah, I think it's cool to see their voting results over the years. Also, with a long result list like ours, the Top isn't as important.
It would be totally cool to have a KKKodex seal of approval whereby it is confirmed that certain games just are excellence. Fallout/Planescape will be in the top spot for the next fifteen years. After that, newfags will up vote some J.E. Sawyer rock-paper-scissors simulator as the top game and what happened to Betrayal at Krondor will happen to Fallout/Planescape.