Once Vita with its screenshot taking magic comes out in Europe, most likely. You see, all that lurking on GAF changed me a bit, and I abandoned piracy. Most games I actually own are on PS3, making them impossible to LP without buying a 300$ dollar capture card. I have some PC games, but almost all of them are in Russian, so they're a poor choice as well. Right now the plan is to LP Persona 4: The Golden (or whatever they're going to rename it to for an English release), as long as it supports screenshot taking. Yes, I do feel guilty about abandoning that thread.
In the meantime, I'll look into the few English PC games I own and see if some of them can be turned into interesting LPs. I believe I remember Heroes of Might & Magic IV having very good campaigns... Or I could LP the first Witcher (thanks to CDPR for providing every language pack to registered users) and bash it mercilessly for being so much worse than Vagrant Story in every way. There's Planescape: Torment, but I'll die of old age before I finish typing all that text. Decisions, decisions.