Well I have looked around for things on Ryl and so far I hear that it really does SUCK.
Anyways, as to the mentality of Codex, it doesn't exist. I really don't know why they call themselves an RPG or an MMORPG forum as all of the games that they like are basically older RPG's and/or text based games.
Codex members that go with the "Codex Way" definately do not know their asses from a hole in the ground considering the fact that, yeah, everyone can bash a game...and not everyone will like a game, but just because gaming styles are different they frown upon it. From what I have seen, there is not a newer game out there that Codex users would like. I am surprised that they didn't waste out DS2 considering it is a good game but not the best.
What surprises me the most is the fact that they all complain about a game being "too open, bland, not linear." If you really think about it, a LINEAR GAME IS MADE TO BE BASIC FOR SIMPLE MINDED PEOPLE THAT JUST WANT TO PLAY A GAME!!!
I have times when I want to just play a game where I go from point A to B and then when done at B, go to C and so on and so forth. But then there are other times when I would like to do what I want in a game. Things like MMORPG's do that since you are able to play where you want when you want, how you want.
What surprises me is that the Codex doesn't like games that are open since they act like they are SO intelligent, yet by far, they are not.
For instance, the thread about the compass that is going to be in Oblivion...tell me one thing Codex, what is the first thing that you do when you apply for a job? Find out what it is about and where it is at. Now how do you find out where it is at? Either a telephone book (with an address) or you call the place and ask for directions. Most games that are doing the openendedness are games that are being real. You find things when you travel in life and you become accostomed to an area meaning you know the area and possibly some of its inhabitants. Now with that, the games are doing the same thing. You will walk around a town, get to know it and then, therefore, be able to go back and know where to find things...JUST LIKE REAL LIFE!
BTW, I love ranting but back on topic now!
So basically, what it comes down to, Codex is a place for people that have either no life or just like to "bring it down on people." That is basically it. The members that you see here with a ton of posts are basically loud mouths who want to let everyone know their moronic opinion. If it were in the real world here, half of you would be fuckin grass considering your attitudes. I am surprised that you guys can make it in life, it really does surprise me!