Realism, maybe.
Bland, by any measure no. From Reviews to fans, just having one amazing place might be enough. Even when it came to Skyrim it was praised and liked. not that they did something amazing, but they had a couple of good pieces.
There was an interview with Todd Howard I think when Skyrim was coming out where he said they didn't think the mass market would accept something as weird as Morrowind but they wanted to be a little stranger than Oblivion, and Skyrim was their happy medium. So that concept of Xbox bros disliking weird settings is definitely out there.