Gruncheon
Savant
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2015
- Messages
- 125
It is the composition of characteristics of the persona, without considering the environment. Annah was not a non-white prodigy born in a ghetto to be raised by a certain society. Annah was still in the ghetto and part of it and her tiefling heritage is nothing out of the ordinary in this environment. While IsObel is a brown person from a chinese ghetto, and therefore she is just for a diversity multicultural reason there and not from a sober prospective and love for the chinese culture. If she would have been chinese or even indonesian or filipino, then this would have been less stupid. Gobbet has so much intersection with chinese culture, as cheese with fucking. So yes in my opinion both characters are shity and shity designed and they do not fit the city. There are many fantastic aspects to the chinese culture that could have been inserted into such a setting, but what we got is more a San Francisco / New York shit.
As far as I remember, Is0bel is meant to be Somalian, her family were refugees and when they arrived in Hong Kong they were moved to the Walled City because it was a dense, low-income housing centre designed for people in their situation. That's not 'black character for the sake of black character', it's a character that has a reason to be there and that illuminates something about the Shadowrun world and Hong Kong. That's the difference between writing diverse characters and pushing an SJW agenda. Diversity is good; it leads to a more interesting breadth of character in RPGs and forces writers to move outside of the same old tropes. It only becomes a problem when character writing is subordinated to the need of the writer to show just how progressive they are.
I do agree that the MC should've been a Hong Kong native, but mainly because I feel it undermined the sense of place in Hong Kong by making you a non-native.