Putting the 'role' back in role-playing games since 2002.
Donate to Codex
Good Old Games
  • Welcome to rpgcodex.net, a site dedicated to discussing computer based role-playing games in a free and open fashion. We're less strict than other forums, but please refer to the rules.

    "This message is awaiting moderator approval": All new users must pass through our moderation queue before they will be able to post normally. Until your account has "passed" your posts will only be visible to yourself (and moderators) until they are approved. Give us a week to get around to approving / deleting / ignoring your mundane opinion on crap before hassling us about it. Once you have passed the moderation period (think of it as a test), you will be able to post normally, just like all the other retards.

CSG update #25 - Weapons, Armor, and Attacks

Goral

Arcane
Patron
The Real Fanboy
Joined
May 4, 2008
Messages
3,552
Location
Poland
http://www.irontowerstudio.com/forum/index.php/topic,7546.0.html

Vault Dweller said:
Since we’re implementing the combat system, let’s go over the weapons, armor, and attack types.

Notable changes from AoD:

  • In AoD all combat skills had a passive effect which grew stronger with every point you put into the skill (i.e. Dodge’s passive ability is Counter-Attack; the higher the skill, the higher the chance to counter-attack when you dodge an attack). The problem was that all dodgers of equal skill level had the same chance to counter-attack, regardless of the weapon or stats. We added a bonus to passive chance for certain weapons to differentiate them more, but it didn’t go far enough. In The New World we move the passive affects to feats, weapons and attack stats, so if you want to have a good chance to counter-attack you’d have to pick proper feats and equip weapons with a high Reaction stat. More on that later.

  • In AoD we had a traditional, linear progression: an iron sword replaced a bronze sword, a steel sword replaced an iron sword, etc. Same weapon model, higher damage (+1 per tier). The New World has 4 tiers representing the overall quality (crude, decent, good, excellent; these are internal tags, so you’ll never see a ‘crude revolver’ in-game) with multiple weapons per tier and different stats (so you can pick whatever weapon that fits your combat style better). To give you an idea, AoD has 40 unique weapon models, The New World has 87 unique weapon models, so you will have plenty to choose from.

  • The downside is that there’s no crafting system. It’s much easier to tell the player that he/she forged a sword that’s better balanced and properly hardened. It’s more complicated with guns as it’s unlikely that your tinkering will add +2 to damage and +1 to penetration.

ihul3cX.png
PgUWIaD.png
xfJGvih.png

^ tier 2 pistols: an all-purpose revolver with a good interrupt chance, a low-accuracy multi-barrel pistol for 'up close and personal' situations, long-barrel pistol for those who favor aimed shots.

Weapon Stats

The stats will include already familiar Fast, Regular, and Power damage (Regular-only for guns, more on that later), attack AP (action-points) cost, range (an important gun stat but two-handed hammers have a longer reach too), ammo type, magazine size, and reload AP cost for guns, and modifiers (bonuses and penalties) affecting your:

- THC (to-hit-chance), some weapons are more accurate than others
- Aimed THC (bonus or penalty given only to aimed attacks; best but not the only example is a scoped rifle)
- Critical chance
- Graze range
- Reaction (your chance to perform counter-attacks and attacks of opportunity)
- Penetration (%-based)
- Stagger (reduce enemy’s AP for the next turn)
- Knockout

The higher the tier, the more modifiers a weapon has (i.e. there's a difference between a pipe pistol made by some thug and a pistol made by a proper gunsmith from machined parts).

Melee combat

Melee combat is mainly the same as in AoD, minus block, spears, and whirlwind (too fantasy). You’ll get the already familiar Fast, Regular, and Power attacks, Aimed attacks, and special attacks like Swing, Double Strike, and Flurry.

The main 3 weapon classes are Fist (brass knuckles, punch daggers, and various combat gloves), Bladed (knives and survival axes), and Blunt (maces and hammers) weapons. Blunt weapons, for example, have the highest Stagger and Knockout modifiers, whereas Bladed weapons have the highest Graze and Critical Chance modifiers. Fist weapons are the fastest and most versatile due to vastly different design.

Compared to Ranged, melee weapons have higher damage (a crude machete will do more damage than a pipe pistol, 6-10 vs 5-8) to compensate for the need to close the distance and make yourself an easy target in the process. They’re also a bit faster (same attack speed but there's no reload), higher chance to score criticals, no THC penalties, but low penetration, penalties instead of bonuses for aimed attacks, and no reaction fire.

Ranged combat

It’s a new design, so let’s go over the key concepts first

  • Unlike melee , your effort doesn’t modify damage, so fast, regular, and aimed attacks do the same damage, which puts the focus on accuracy (i.e. the longer you aim, the higher your accuracy). Thus unlike melee Fast attack that gives you a THC bonus, ranged Snap Shot gives you a THC penalty; similarly melee Aimed attacks give you a THC penalty as they are easier to dodge, whereas ranged Aimed Attacks give you a THC bonus, so the concepts are reversed.

  • Range is an important stat for balance purposes (shotguns do a lot of damage up close but lose their accuracy fast, rifles take longer to aim and fire than pistols but have a long range). For example, the famous Sten SMG was described as wildly inaccurate beyond 30 meters, so weapons with short effective ranges are certainly realistic.

  • Each tier (i.e quality) increases damage, accuracy, and modifiers, representing better quality and precision, but not by far. Whereas in Wasteland 2 the starting pistol does 5-8 points of damage and the endgame pistol does 100-135, in The New World a pipe pistol does the same 5-8 points of damage and the best unique pistol does 9-14 points of damage, but the overall quality increases accuracy, range, penetration, which are equally important stats.

  • So while all pistols of the same tier (i.e. same quality) that use the same ammo do the same damage, we ‘randomize’ the system via bullet types:
    - 9mm – generic, no modifiers, cheapest
    - 0.45 – heavy bullet, damage +1, packs a strong punch (bonus to stagger), higher chance to cause critical
    - 5.56 – light bullet for high velocity guns (rifles and long SMGs), - 1 to damage, +10 to magazine size, +10 to penetration
    - Shotgun shell – high CS, high graze, penalty to penetration
    - Energy cell – its own group, doesn’t mix with the rest. The unique trait is that each cell contains 10 charges; pistols take 1 per shot, so 10 shots, rifles take 2, so 5 shots, cannons take 5, so 2 per cell but they do massive damage. Mechanics wise it’s like a burst where you fire several bullets at once.

  • Penetration – instead of going with a vsDR value that reduces enemy’s DR by a fixed amount, we’ll go with % that would either increase or decrease the armor DR value, similar to how different arrowheads worked in AoD.

  • As mentioned in the past, there are 3 firearm types (pistols, rifles, and SMG) and each type has 3 subtypes. For example, rifles include one-handed guns like sawed-off shotguns and “mare’s leg” type short rifles, shotguns, and proper rifles, ranging from bolt-action to sniper rifles, so if you specialize in rifles, you won’t be stuck with the same type of weapon doing the same thing.

  • Attack types: Snap Shot, Regular, Aimed: Head, Central Mass (torso), Arms, Legs, Bullseye (+6AP, highest bonuses if hit), Fanning for revolvers, Double Shot for multi-barrel guns, Short Burst, and Long Burst.

  • Graze range – As mentioned previously, I wanted to implement it in AoD but we were out of time and the fast attacks were basically grazing attacks, doing a lot less damage. The ranged combat is perfect for it. Let’s say you have 80% THC (to-hit chance). You roll the dice and as luck would have it, you’re 1 point short but the binary miss-hit system doesn’t reward your near excellence and treats it as you weren’t even close. So, we’ll change that and go with 4 roll 'ranges': miss, graze, hit, critical hit (instead of rolling for critical separately). This will give us some flexibility with damage ranges and allow you to trade damage for THC.

UTyp64E.png

A tier 2 one-handed shotgun, damage 8-11, THC -5, Aimed THC -10, CS chance +10, Graze range +15, Penetration -20%, Stagger +15%, Knockdown +5%

Attack Types

Attack types will modify:

- AP cost
- Damage (melee only)
- THC
- Graze range
- Critical range
- Effect (stat penalty, penetration, knockdown, etc)
- Critical damage
- Critical Effect

The stat/skill, feat, weapons, and attack type modifiers add up and increase the desired effect. For example, if you pick up a shotgun with high graze range and use attacks that increase this range even more, you will rarely miss. Similarly, Prizefighter (feat) goes well together with brass knuckles and reinforced, tactical gloves, which in turn are better for Aimed: Head attacks than knives, greatly increasing your chance to knock ‘em out.

Armor

There are 4 armor slots (which brings us a step closer to a multi-piece armor for a future game): helmet, tactical vest, jacket or coat, boots & leg armor (kneecaps and such). Plus goggles and breathers. Aimed shots will target individual body parts and thus armor that protects them, general shots will have to get through vest’s and jacket’s combined DR.

There are 3 damage types (which brings us a step closer to a more complex damage system in a future game): melee, projectile, energy, which means there are 3 different DR types and different upgrade materials, each with its pros and cons: metal, synthetic fiber (i.e. Kevlar), ceramic plates.

5A6sb1v.png

A scav in full gear, a rent-a-guard, a thug with a fashionable welding mask and ballistic armor, a raider dressed for success.

1ToU6nV.png

A fully upgraded raiders' coat with a powered pre-mutiny chest armor.

That's about it, unless I missed something.
 

Goral

Arcane
Patron
The Real Fanboy
Joined
May 4, 2008
Messages
3,552
Location
Poland
whirlwind (too fantasy)
I disagree, in certain situations a move like that would be definitely a viable option. Centrifugal force is a force to be reckoned with, what's fantasy is suggesting that going to a gun fight with a knife has equal or almost equal chances which will happen in your game so that melee won't be useless.It was a cool move, why remove it?
low penetration
A knife would penetrate a bulletproof vest much easier than a bullet from a small calibre gun (unless it would have a metal plate). Just saying, I realize it's a game. BTW, will there be knuckles with spikes like in Fallout?
hrciNBX.png

Attack types: Snap Shot, Regular, Aimed: Head, Central Mass (torso), Arms, Legs, Bullseye (+6AP, highest bonuses if hit), Fanning for revolvers, Double Shot for multi-barrel guns, Short Burst, and Long Burst.
Give us groin attacks (and proper animations for it) dammit! That way you will be able to interest kids with your game just like Fallout did :]. And add dumdum bullets which are still being used on airplanes because they rarely pass through targets.

Edit:
After reading the whole thing, why can't we put on more than one armour, so for example metal armour and kevlar armour on it for better protection?
 
Last edited:

Vault Dweller

Commissar, Red Star Studio
Developer
Joined
Jan 7, 2003
Messages
28,024
whirlwind (too fantasy)
I disagree, in certain situations a move like that would be definitely a viable option. Centrifugal force is a force to be reckoned with, what's fantasy is suggesting that going to a gun fight with a knife has equal or almost equal chances which will happen in your game so that melee won't be useless.It was a cool move, why remove it?
First, melee is mainly a backup weapon for all fighters (when you run out of bullets), second, if you choose to specialize in melee, you won't just charge and hope for the best. You'd use smoke grenades to reduce visibility and gadgets. Second, we still have Swing (hits 3 tiles), so that's something.

A knife would penetrate a bulletproof vest much easier than a bullet from a small calibre gun (unless it would have a metal plate). Just saying, I realize it's a game.
I meant in general, against metal or more advanced armor. Low-tech ballistic armor won't be very effective against melee weapons.

BTW, will there be knuckles with spikes like in Fallout?
hrciNBX.png
lfww2TA.png

Bonus to penetration.

After reading the whole thing, why can't we put on more than one armour, so for example metal armour and kevlar armour on it for better protection?
You can't put on two vests but you can reinforce that ballistic armor with metal stripes and look like a Roman legionnaire (can't find the concept and Mazin's away now). Basically, that's the idea with upgrade slots, you can mix and match.
 

Ibn Sina

Arbiter
Patron
Joined
Jul 12, 2017
Messages
921
Strap Yourselves In
I have a question concerning energy weapons. On most updates you made you always emphasized on the rarity of energy cells and weapons. Yet when I saw the preview of the character screen energy weapons had their own skill slots, and 3 separate skills no less! (For guns, rifles and cannons). I am afraid that this will be a case of redundant skills like the ones in AoD that are rarely used ex Etiquette. Why would someone waste skill points on something that will be rarely used or found. Would it not be more feasible to tie energy weapon skill to ballistics or at least roll them all in one skill?
 

Vault Dweller

Commissar, Red Star Studio
Developer
Joined
Jan 7, 2003
Messages
28,024
First, one wouldn't waste skill points because there aren't any (you increase skills by using). Second, even if we had skill points, the energy weapons are very powerful and thus worth investing into. It's an ace in your sleeve, basically. Like a pirate who carried two loaded flintlocks and a cutlass, your typical adventurer might have an energy pistol charged to fire a shot or two on special occasions, a .45 revolver, an SMG with two full magazines to get you out of tight spots fast, and an axe, for when things get really dicey.
 

Vault Dweller

Commissar, Red Star Studio
Developer
Joined
Jan 7, 2003
Messages
28,024
Skills will have different ratios at which they increase, depending on how often/rarely they are used.
Yes, but the point is whether energy weapons will be useful even if you have lower or underveloped skills.
In general, they are more accurate (better design and no recoil), so you'll be able to learn how to use them faster. Low skills will always be a factor but you'd have to start somewhere. Keep using them and you'll get better. Or sell the energy cells and buy yourself something nice instead.
 
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
1,301
Grab the Codex by the pussy
In general, they are more accurate (better design and no recoil), so you'll be able to learn how to use them faster. Low skills will always be a factor but you'd have to start somewhere. Keep using them and you'll get better. Or sell the energy cells and buy yourself something nice instead.
I understand the narrative rationale behind scarcity of ammo in general and the superior technology of energy weapons in particular, but this is in direct tension with the learn by use system, which creates an incentive for more specialisation. If energy cells are limited and their use will prevent me from developing another skill which is not limited by the scarcity of resources (let’s say, melee weapons), why should I waste the opportunity of improving my ability even further and becoming more specialised? I understand that they are better weapons, but the trade-off is not good enough in the long run. If I wanted to use a more potent auxiliary weapon in AoD (e.g., bolas or bombs), this would not prevent me from receiving my hard-earned SPs, but in TnW I will lose SPs if I decide to use energy weapons in a certain sense, which will eventually become discharged.
 

Vault Dweller

Commissar, Red Star Studio
Developer
Joined
Jan 7, 2003
Messages
28,024
In general, they are more accurate (better design and no recoil), so you'll be able to learn how to use them faster. Low skills will always be a factor but you'd have to start somewhere. Keep using them and you'll get better. Or sell the energy cells and buy yourself something nice instead.
I understand the narrative rationale behind scarcity of ammo in general and the superior technology of energy weapons in particular, but this is in direct tension with the learn by use system, which creates an incentive for more specialisation. If energy cells are limited and their use will prevent me from developing another skill which is not limited by the scarcity of resources (let’s say, melee weapons), why should I waste the opportunity of improving my ability even further and becoming more specialised?
Because they're vastly more powerful and the ammo scarcity is more of a balance factor than narrative, thus you'll get a much higher return on your investment.
 

curry

Arcane
Joined
Jan 10, 2011
Messages
4,010
Location
Cooking in the lab
In general, they are more accurate (better design and no recoil), so you'll be able to learn how to use them faster. Low skills will always be a factor but you'd have to start somewhere. Keep using them and you'll get better. Or sell the energy cells and buy yourself something nice instead.
I understand the narrative rationale behind scarcity of ammo in general and the superior technology of energy weapons in particular, but this is in direct tension with the learn by use system, which creates an incentive for more specialisation. If energy cells are limited and their use will prevent me from developing another skill which is not limited by the scarcity of resources (let’s say, melee weapons), why should I waste the opportunity of improving my ability even further and becoming more specialised?
Because they're vastly more powerful and the ammo scarcity is more of a balance factor than narrative, thus you'll get a much higher return on your investment.
Then why should anyone put skill points in melee instead of energy weapons?
 
Joined
Jan 18, 2018
Messages
1,301
Grab the Codex by the pussy
Then why should anyone put skill points in melee instead of energy weapons?
Exactly. I think it is because they will allow you to be lazy in combat and win without planning. Energy weapons will be overpowered like bombs were in AoD. If you can't beat some enemies fair and square, use your energy weapons and be done with it. It’s the only rationale I can think of. Otherwise it is not worth it.
 

Vault Dweller

Commissar, Red Star Studio
Developer
Joined
Jan 7, 2003
Messages
28,024
Then why should anyone put skill points in melee instead of energy weapons?
First, there are no skill points. Second, the energy ammo IS rare, which means that quite often you won't have any at all. Melee weapons are backup weapons, when you run out of all ammo, energy and firearms.

Exactly. I think it is because they will allow you to be lazy in combat and win without planning. Energy weapons will be overpowered like bombs were in AoD. If you can't beat some enemies fair and square, use your energy weapons and be done with it. It’s the only rationale I can think of. Otherwise it is not worth it.
It's not the goal.
 

Vault Dweller

Commissar, Red Star Studio
Developer
Joined
Jan 7, 2003
Messages
28,024
It will be feasible (feats, smoke grenades to reduce ranger's visibility, etc), but most enemies will use guns, if only to fire a shot or two before switching to melee.
 

Goral

Arcane
Patron
The Real Fanboy
Joined
May 4, 2008
Messages
3,552
Location
Poland
IMO it would be interesting if you would use Jagged Alliance approach where our performance in combat would be affected by our health condition or add it as an optional feature for those seeking higher challenges. "After all it's hard to perform any job well when your arm is falling off".
 

Vault Dweller

Commissar, Red Star Studio
Developer
Joined
Jan 7, 2003
Messages
28,024
We've considered it several times, both for AoD and TNW, but this feature will only increase meta-gaming (got hit? reload because your THC just went down by 5%!). Since this feature will drastically alter the balance, even though it's easy to implement, it will take a lot of time to balance, so it's unlikely that we'll have time to add it.
 

As an Amazon Associate, rpgcodex.net earns from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top Bottom