- Joined
- Jan 28, 2011
- Messages
- 97,443
Once again, PoE tries to have it both ways by making its elves oppressed native Glanfathans and haughty colonialist Aedyrans.
It could be argued that race determinants a lot of the ideologies,religions and nations. But seeing that it is Obsidian,races are born randomly around the world and every nation is a melting pot of different races and there is no racism in the world.Maybe their idea is that whatever racial differences there are, they are ultimately meaningless in the face of ideologies, technology and nations. But that would require a subtler hand than I think they are capable of anymore. There's also the problem of all the major races' physiology being based on the human one, so they don't require special circumstances to operate and they'd naturally congregate and develop in the same way humans do. Which goes back to the question of why have fantasy races.
But seeing that it is Obsidian,races are born randomly around the world and every nation is a melting pot of different races and there is no racism in the world.
Are you talking about the rat dwarf people?But seeing that it is Obsidian,races are born randomly around the world and every nation is a melting pot of different races and there is no racism in the world.
Yeah, definitely never saw any kind of racism in PoE, no siree
Yes but the consequence of this would be precisely to recognize that diversity exists on the civilized, meaning, colonial or imperial level of political organization. Why is racial diversity constant throughout all of the game's cultures independent of ideology, technological level, etc, meaning it isn't really a matter of ideology at all (if i recall correctly, each culture is arbitrarily populated by a majority of two races with a smattering of the other races). There's no sense that any of these races originated anywhere in particular. It's as if you tried to imagine a 16th century Puritan America with current day America's demographics, ignoring how it is that those demographics are produced to begin with. How are races even maintained and distinct if no one cares about race? The game makes these gestures at reproducing real world prejudices in the form of orlan hatred, but this is hardly relevant. The population of this world should have bred into some super race by now rendering the issue null and void. Unless crossbreeding is impossible--which brings us back to the original problem (isn't it only humans and elves that intermarry? I'm probably entirely wrong on this point).It is borrowing "some" themes from arcanum as well as our own colonial history where massive mobilization, technological advancement, colonialism made different between races minimal, and national identity matters more than your race.
Of course, the way it is presented is too fluid for the level of technology but whatever, i take this over the generic elf vs dwarf conflict
Unless crossbreeding is impossible--which brings us back to the original problem (isn't it only humans and elves that intermarry? I'm probably entirely wrong on this point)
There's no sense that any of these races originated anywhere in particular. It's as if you tried to imagine a 16th century Puritan America with current day America's demographics, ignoring how it is that those demographics are produced to begin with.
I mean, maybe these things (and other similar questions) have been addressed somewhere in the lore that I'm not aware of, but none of what I've read is very convincing.
Yes they have. As I've said other times though, PoE is notorious for not making enough use of its own lore.
The Aedyran lore book is very informative--I'm a bit surprised I never bothered to read it (or don't remember reading it--it's been a while). But my questions about the implausibility of the game world's historical development still hold.There's no sense that any of these races originated anywhere in particular. It's as if you tried to imagine a 16th century Puritan America with current day America's demographics, ignoring how it is that those demographics are produced to begin with.
I mean, maybe these things (and other similar questions) have been addressed somewhere in the lore that I'm not aware of, but none of what I've read is very convincing.
They have, in broad strokes. Humans and elves in Aedyr:
https://pillarsofeternity.gamepedia.com/The_Aedyr_Empire,_Part_1:_Origin
https://pillarsofeternity.gamepedia.com/Wodewys
Origins of races:
https://pillarsofeternity.gamepedia.com/Human#Subtypes
https://pillarsofeternity.gamepedia.com/Elf#Pale_Elves
Greetings Watchers!
This Wednesday at 4PM PDT, we're be showing off a new area in Pillars of Eternity II: Deadfire on our twitch channel!